EvidenceBased Decision MakingEvidenceBased Decision Making

A rapidly spreading movement in the medical profession is evidence-based decision making. The business community has also begun to take notice. Pfeffer and Sutton's recent ?Harvard Business Review? article argues for evidence-based decision making in business management.

Physicians using evidence-based decision making are committed to identifying, disseminating, and applying the latest research that is soundly conducted and clinically relevant. While this makes common sense, it is not common practice.

Thousands of studies of medical practice are conducted each year. You may find the research findings disturbing. Only 15% of medical decisions are evidence based!

What do physicians rely on the other 85% of the time? It appears to be a combination of the following:

- generally accepted, but never proven, tradition

- methods in which they are most skilled

- information from vendors of products and services

- obsolete knowledge acquired in medical school

Pfeffer and Sutton believe, 'managers are actually much more ignorant than doctors about which prescriptions are reliable?and less eager to find out.? A harsh accusation, but one containing a serious reason for concern.

I should point out that Pfeffer and Sutton's research focuses on ?how companies ought to be managed? (their own words). Their prescriptive, rather than descriptive, conclusions often clash with the reality of real-world business decision making. Nevertheless, their work reveals opportunities for improving our decision making effectiveness.

As I stated in my book, ?Strategic Organizational Learning,? competence in any profession (medicine, management, or consulting) depends largely on the tacit knowledge gained from experience. While I am an advocate for seeking real-world professional experience, our experience will always be limited.

Pfeffer and Sutton, correctly state, ?Seasoned practitioners sometimes neglect to seek out new evidence because they trust their own clinical experience more than they trust research.? They go on to say, ?information acquired firsthand often feels richer and closer to real knowledge than do words and data in a journal article.?

So, what am I suggesting? Should you discount the hard-earned tacit knowledge you have acquired over many years of professional work? Of course not. But, I do recommend that you become any active member of a community of practice, read the journals in your field, and always question what you ?know.?

To read more about this topic, I recommend Pfeffer and Sutton's new book, ?Hard Facts, Dangerous Half-Truths, and Total Nonsense: Profiting from Evidence-Based Management? (Harvard Business School Press).

by Michael Beitler
References and Bibliography

Dr. Mike Beitler is the author of "Strategic Organizational Learning." Read 2 free chapters from the book online at http://www.strategic-organizational-learning.com

Rated:NR/0 Votes
Add To My Article Reading List
Add To My Article Reading List
Print Article
More Article By Michael Beitler
More Article by Michael Beitler
More Articles From Management
More Articles From Management
Related Articles and Readings
Burger on a Bun Decision Making By: George Ebert
When approaching any decision, it's important for individuals to maintain the healthy state of openness called for by WYSINWYG (what you see is never what you get). Remember that there is always more going on than simply meets the eye. Calling on all the skills, strengths and resources that are ...
Build Your Career Decision By Decision By: Ramon Greenwood
Do you dislike making decisions and avoid the challenge whenever you can?Take heart. Look around and you will find you have plenty of company.Management psychologists Irving L. Janis and Leon Mann say people tend to be 'reluctant decision makers? because they are ?beset by conflict, doubts and worry.? ...
Decision Making By: Christopher J Thomas
Recent studies have shown that industrial supervisors are working at less than 60 % of their potential. Basic management skills training is guaranteed to change all this and at such little costIntroductionOne of the world's most memorable quotes is from Shakespeare's Hamlet - to be or not to be is ...
Things To Consider When Making A Decision About Divorce By: Karl Augustine
When making a divorce decision, there are quite a few things that you should consider. Too often people find themselves unable to clearly identify what they need to think about when making a divorce decision which leads to further indecision and frustration. When making serious divorce decisions, having an open ...
Successful Business Decision Making By: Terri Zwierzynski
Some people make decisions without any difficulty, while others struggle. Are you having trouble making a decision? Do you feel overwhelmed by all the choices you have, and aren't sure how to pick just one? No matter how big or small those decisions might be, I can teach you how ...
The information provided in this article and/or the comments is the sole responsibility of their respective authors and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of ezinepost.com. ezinepost.com  does not endorse any article and/or comments published by our web users unless otherwise noted. 

Member Panel

login to submit articles and more


  • » Active Categories: 419
  • » Active Articles:252603
  • » Active Authors:31917
  • » Active Members: 38237
  • » Statistics Updated:
    - Tue Sep 1st, 2020 09:28AM EST