Birth Of An Industry: Backlink CertificationBirth Of An Industry: Backlink Certification

The recent Google-JCPenny ranking controversy only highlighted what has been apparent for some time: Google and the other search engines are less effective at suppressing link spam than they are given credit for. I believe part of the problem lies with AdWords, which makes attempts to match the relevancy of keywords to landing pages. In fact, if you attempt to use wildly inappropriate keywords for your landing page searches, Google will jack up you CPC to the point where it's unprofitable to use those keywords.

Why Didn't Google Recognize JCPenny LinkSpam?

If Google can evaluate keywords, why didn't it identify JCPenny link spam, forum spam, blog spam, etc? There are, I believe, two answers: (a) Google isn't as good at detection as it claims, and (b) for various reasons, Google wasn't motivated to apply what knowledge it had. Ultimately, the reasons really don't matter; the fact remains that as long as Google uses its current system of ranking websites based on number of backlinks, there will be plenty of opportunity for abuse.

In light of the JCPenny scandal, what should the search providers do? The most extreme reaction is simply to ignore backlinks. Talk about throwing out the baby and the bathwater! What would be the replacement proxy for popularity?

I propose that search engines separate popularity from authority. These are two different concepts and should be handled as such. Bernie Madoff's Ponzi scheme was very popular....

The Proposed Model

The bond industry has a relevant model. Companies like S&P and Moody's rate bonds so that the market can properly evaluate bond prices. Yes, I'm aware that the bond ratings scandals in 2008 helped propel us into an enormous economic mess. The solution was to remove the conflict of interest in how the rating companies were paid, certainly not to abolish ratings.

Let's extend the model to the backlink business. First, can we hypothesize that, say, 100,000 backlinks to a single site is suspicious. How about 10,000? 1,000? At some point, the sheer number of links should become a negative. Second, let's agree that an automated webcrawler, can quickly determine if a backlink is "real" in the sense that the linked entities associate related content. Thus, our model is a company with a realistic number of proven backlinks that wants the search engines to reward them for having "good" links.

In this model, five certified links to Sears would have outranked 10,000 bad links to JCPenny.

Backlink Certification

Cue the backlink certifiers. Imagine a dedicated phalanx of webcrawlers whose sole job is to evaluate the legitimacy of links; it certifies the honest ones and assigns them serial numbers. The serial number data would be made available to all subscribing search engines. The search engines would now have a new means for ranking websites rather than just relying on unevaluated links. Only quality links would be used to rank websites -- a practice that would have exposed JCPenny. To keep the certifier's honest, set up an industry watchdog to look into abuses and deal with bad actors.

One may ask: why not just let each search engine do these link evaluations? Well, first, I don't trust them. They are in a conflicted position as witnessed by JCPenny, which is a large paid advertiser. Second, uniformity of results can only arise if a common mechanism is employed. Third, cover - the certifier would take the heat from parties disagreeing with its judgment, shielding the search engine companies from some of the direct pressure.

I can hear the pessimists now: too costly, too time-consuming, won't work, will be gamed, etc. To them I say: establish a pilot project. Let's put it to the test. Let the search engine industry support an institute for link certification, and apply to it all the lessons learned from the bond-rating industry circa 2008. The industry would be encouraged to contribute its various link content evaluation algorithms to assist in differentiating good links from spam.

Keep it Private

The search engines, especially Google, right now are facing a credibility crisis, so they are under pressure to do something. If this proposal works, black-hat SEOs will be faced with a new challenge to overcome. If it fails, at least it was tried, and whatever costs involved can easily be absorbed by Google, Microsoft and Yahoo!.

A few caveats: leave the government out of it, maintain a low price tag for a link certification and agree beforehand on all the rules for evaluating the appropriateness of a link. For those who think it's too expensive, how much money would JCPenny's competitors have paid to expose the underhanded behavior before they lost millions in online sales to JCPenny?

The demand for a new link evaluation paradigm is real. Anyone care to fund it?
by Eric Bank
References and Bibliography
Based in Knoxville, Tenn., Eric Bank has been a freelance writer of business-related articles since 1985. He holds a Master of Business Administration from New York University and an Master of Science in Finance from DePaul University. Eric freelances through http://ericbank.Com.
Rated:NR/0 Votes
Add To My Article Reading List
Add To My Article Reading List
Print Article
More Article By Eric Bank
More Article by Eric Bank
More Articles From Search Engines
More Articles From Search Engines
Related Articles and Readings
Search Engines The Masters Of The Internet Universe Part 2 By: Vinodh Pushparaj
?This is a continuation of the pervious part, split into multiple parts for keeping the article size manageable.?When we thought we are just boxed in by the same set of search engine perspectives, there it comes, ?help? flapping its wide wings in the form of meta-search engines. These search engines ...
Search Engines 101 Search Engines Explained By: Kristy Meghreblian
What Are Search Engines?A search engine is a database system designed to index and categorize internet addresses, otherwise known as URLs (for example, are four basic types of search engines:Automatic: These search engines are based on information that is collected, sorted and analyzed by software programs, commonly referred to ...
Getting Unlimited Traffic From Search Engines By: Kusuma Widjaja
Search engines have become so intimidating lately - most people think that search engines are just out to get them - everyone's becoming afraid... They also think that getting #1 rankings is near impossible.Yes, if you're trying to trick search engines, THEN - they're out to get you - BIG ...
The SEO Approach - Know Search Engines, Do not Submit to Them! By: Hassan Sayed
Search engines are attracted to website content, they take this content and apply every technology available, every useful idea, and now even the behavior of your visitors towards your content to compare and rank your website. ...
Three Easy Ways to Improve Your Rankings in the Search Engines By: Jinger Jarrett
Getting to the top of the search engines and being found by potential customers is no easy task. In fact, it takes a lot of time and energy to develop an effective search engine strategy for your business.This is probably the reason that none of the "gurus" ever talk about ...
The information provided in this article and/or the comments is the sole responsibility of their respective authors and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of  does not endorse any article and/or comments published by our web users unless otherwise noted. 

Member Panel

login to submit articles and more


  • » Active Categories: 419
  • » Active Articles:251893
  • » Active Authors:32244
  • » Active Members: 31843
  • » Statistics Updated:
    - Sun Apr 1st, 2018 06:13PM EST